You are not currently logged in.

Access your personal account or get JSTOR access through your library or other institution:


Log in to your personal account or through your institution.

Homosexuality as a Consequence of Epigenetically Canalized Sexual Development

William R. Rice, Urban Friberg and Sergey Gavrilets
The Quarterly Review of Biology
Vol. 87, No. 4 (December 2012), pp. 343-368
DOI: 10.1086/668167
Stable URL:
Page Count: 26
Subjects: Biological Sciences Ecology & Evolutionary Biology History of Science & Technology
  • Download PDF
  • Add to My Lists
  • Cite this Item
Homosexuality as a Consequence of Epigenetically Canalized Sexual Development
We're having trouble loading this content. Download PDF instead.


ABSTRACTMale and female homosexuality have substantial prevalence in humans. Pedigree and twin studies indicate that homosexuality has substantial heritability in both sexes, yet concordance between identical twins is low and molecular studies have failed to find associated DNA markers. This paradoxical pattern calls for an explanation. We use published data on fetal androgen signaling and gene regulation via nongenetic changes in DNA packaging (epigenetics) to develop a new model for homosexuality. It is well established that fetal androgen signaling strongly influences sexual development. We show that an unappreciated feature of this process is reduced androgen sensitivity in XX fetuses and enhanced sensitivity in XY fetuses, and that this difference is most feasibly caused by numerous sex-specific epigenetic modifications (“epi-marks”) originating in embryonic stem cells. These epi-marks buffer XX fetuses from masculinization due to excess fetal androgen exposure and similarly buffer XY fetuses from androgen underexposure. Extant data indicates that individual epi-marks influence some but not other sexually dimorphic traits, vary in strength across individuals, and are produced during ontogeny and erased between generations. Those that escape erasure will steer development of the sexual phenotypes they influence in a gonad-discordant direction in opposite sex offspring, mosaically feminizing XY offspring and masculinizing XX offspring. Such sex-specific epi-marks are sexually antagonistic (SA-epi-marks) because they canalize sexual development in the parent that produced them, but contribute to gonad-trait discordances in opposite-sex offspring when unerased. In this model, homosexuality occurs when stronger-than-average SA-epi-marks (influencing sexual preference) from an opposite-sex parent escape erasure and are then paired with a weaker-than-average de novo sex-specific epi-marks produced in opposite-sex offspring. Our model predicts that homosexuality is part of a wider phenomenon in which recently evolved androgen-influenced traits commonly display gonad-trait discordances at substantial frequency, and that the molecular feature underlying most homosexuality is not DNA polymorphism(s), but epi-marks that evolved to canalize sexual dimorphic development that sometimes carryover across generations and contribute to gonad-trait discordances in opposite-sex descendants.

Notes and References

This item contains 107 references.

  • ['Ahmed S. F., Dobbie R., Finlayson A. R., Gilbert J., Youngson G., Chalmers J., Stone D. 2004. Prevalence of hypospadias and other genital anomalies among singleton births, 1988–1997, in Scotland. Archives of Disease in Childhood; Fetal and Neonatal Edition 89:F149–F151.']
  • ['Akimoto C. et al. 2010. Testis-specific protein on Y chromosome (TSPY) represses the activity of the androgen receptor in androgen-dependent testicular germ-cell tumors. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 107:19891–19896.']
  • ['Alanko K., Santtila P., Harlaar N., Witting K., Varjonen M., Jern P., Johansson A., von der Pahlen B., Sandnabba N. K. 2010. Common genetic effects of gender atypical behavior in childhood and sexual orientation in adulthood: a study of Finnish twins. Archives of Sexual Behavior 39:81–92.']
  • ['Arnold A. P., Chen X. 2009. What does the “four core genotypes” mouse model tell us about sex differences in the brain and other tissues? Frontiers in Neuroendocrinology 30:1–9.']
  • ['Arnqvist G., Rowe L. 2005. Sexual Conflict. Princeton (New Jersey): Princeton University Press.']
  • ['Bailey J. M., Dunne M. P., Martin N. G. 2000. Genetic and environmental influences on sexual orientation and its correlates in an Australian twin sample. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 78:524–536.']
  • ['Bailey N. W., Zuk M. 2009. Same-sex sexual behavior and evolution. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 24:439–446.']
  • ['Bao A.-M., Liu R.-Y., van Someren E. J. W., Hofman M. A., Cao Y.-X., Zhou J.-N. 2003. Diurnal rhythm of free estradiol during the menstrual cycle. European Journal of Endocrinology 148:227–232.']
  • ['Bay K., Main K. M., Toppari J., Skakkebæk N. E. 2011. Testicular descent: INSL3, testosterone, genes and the intrauterine milieu. Nature Reviews Urology 8:187–196.']
  • ['Bermejo-Alvarez P., Rizos D., Rath D., Lonergan P., Gutierrez-Adan A. 2010. Sex determines the expression level of one third of the actively expressed genes in bovine blastocysts. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 107:3394–3399.']
  • ['Bermejo-Alvarez P., Rizos D., Lonergan P., Gutierrez-Adan A. 2011. Transcriptional sexual dimorphism during preimplantation embryo development and its consequences for developmental competence and adult health and disease. Reproduction 141:563–570.']
  • ['Blanchard R., Lippa R. A. 2007. Birth order, sibling sex ratio, handedness, and sexual orientation of male and female participants in a BBC internet research project. Archives of Sexual Behavior 36:163–176.']
  • ['Boehmer A. L. M., Brinkmann A. O., Nijman R. M., Verleun-Mooijman M. C. T., de Ruiter P., Niermeijer M. F., Drop S. L. S. 2001. Phenotypic variation in a family with partial androgen insensitivity syndrome explained by differences in 5α dihydrotestosterone availability. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism 86:1240–1246.']
  • ['Bogaert A. F., Skorska M. 2011. Sexual orientation, fraternal birth order, and the maternal immune hypothesis: a review. Frontiers in Neuroendocrinology 32:247–254.']
  • ['Boisen K. A., Chellakooty M., Schmidt I. M., Kai C. M., Damgaard I. N., Suomi A.-M., Toppari J., Skakkebaek N. E., Main K. M. 2005. Hypospadias in a cohort of 1072 Danish newborn boys: prevalence and relationship to placental weight, anthropometrical measurements at birth, and reproductive hormone levels at three months of age. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism 90:4041–4046.']
  • ['Bonduriansky R., Chenoweth S. F. 2009. Intralocus sexual conflict. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 24:280–288.']
  • ['Bouchard T. J., Jr., Lykken D. T., McGue M., Segal N. L., Tellegen A. 1990. Sources of human psychological differences: the Minnesota Study of Twins Reared Apart. Science 250:223–228.']
  • ['Burri A., Cherkas L., Spector T., Rahman Q. 2011. Genetic and environmental influences on female sexual orientation, childhood gender typicality and adult gender identity. PLoS ONE 6:e21982.']
  • ['Camperio-Ciani A., Corna F., Capiluppi C. 2004. Evidence for maternally inherited factors favouring male homosexuality and promoting female fecundity. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 271:2217–2221.']
  • ['Camperio-Ciani A., Cermelli P., Zanzotto G. 2008. Sexually antagonistic selection in human male homosexuality. PLoS ONE 3:e2282.']
  • ['Cantor J. M., Blanchard R., Paterson A. D., Bogaert A. F. 2002. How many gay men owe their sexual orientation to fraternal birth order? Archives of Sexual Behavior 31:63–71.']
  • ['Carmina E. 1998. Prevalence of idiopathic hirsutism. European Journal of Endocrinology 139:421–423.']
  • ['Chapman T., Arnqvist G., Bangham J., Rowe L. 2003. Sexual conflict. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 18: 41–47.']
  • ['Cold C. J., McGrath K. A. 1999. Anatomy and histology of the penile and clitoral prepuce in primates: evolutionary perspective of specialised sensory tissue of the external genitalia. Pages 19–30 in Male and Female Circumcision: Medical, Legal, and Ethical Considerations in Pediatric Practice, edited by G. C. Denniston, F. M. Hodges, and M. F. Milos. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers.']
  • ['Davies W., Wilkinson L. S. 2006. It is not all hormones: alternative explanations for sexual differentiation of the brain. Brain Research 1126:36–45.']
  • ['Dewing P., Shi T., Horvath S., Vilain E. 2003. Sexually dimorphic gene expression in mouse brain precedes gonadal differentiation. Molecular Brain Research 118:82–90.']
  • ['Eberhard W. G. 1996. Female Control: Sexual Selection by Cryptic Female Choice. Princeton (New Jersey): Princeton University Press.']
  • ['Fang H., Tong W., Branham W. S., Moland C. L., Dial S. L., Hong H., Xie Q., Perkins R., Owens W., Sheehan D. M. 2003. Study of 202 natural, synthetic, and environmental chemicals for binding to the androgen receptor. Chemical Research in Toxicology 16:1338–1358.']
  • ['Fiddler M., Abdel-Rahman B., Rappolee D. A., Pergament E. 1995. Expression of SRY transcripts in preimplantation human embryos. American Journal of Medical Genetics 55:80–84.']
  • ['Forest M. G. 1985. Pitfalls in prenatal diagnosis of 21-hydroxylase deficiency by amniotic fluid steroid analysis? A six years experience in 102 pregnancies at risk. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 458:130–147.']
  • ['Fouse S. D., Shen Y., Pellegrini M., Cole S., Meissner A., Van Neste L., Jaenisch R., Fan G. 2008. Promoter CpG methylation contributes to ES cell gene regulation in parallel with Oct4/Nanog, PcG complex, and histone H3 K4/K27 trimethylation. Cell Stem Cell 2:160–169.']
  • ['Franklin T. B., Russig H., Weiss I. C., Gräff J., Linder N., Michalon A., Vizi S., Mansuy I. M. 2010. Epigenetic transmission of the impact of early stress across generations. Biological Psychiatry 68:408–415.']
  • ['Fredell L., Kockum I., Hansson E., Holmner S., Lundquist L., Läckgren G., Pedersen J., Stenberg A., Westbacke G., Nordenskjöld A. 2002. Heredity of hypospadias and the significance of low birth weight. Journal of Urology 167:1423–1427.']
  • ['Furrow R. E., Christiansen F. B., Feldman M. W. 2011. Environment-sensitive epigenetics and the heritability of complex disease. Genetics 189:1377–1387.']
  • ['Gardner D. K., Larman M. G., Thouas G. A. 2010. Sex-related physiology of the preimplantation embryo. Molecular Human Reproduction 16:539–547.']
  • ['Gärtner K., Baunack E. 1981. Is the similarity of monozygotic twins due to genetic factors alone? Nature 292:646–647.']
  • ['Gavrilets S. 2000. Rapid evolution of reproductive barriers driven by sexual conflict. Nature 403:886–889.']
  • ['Gavrilets S., Hayashi T. I. 2005. Speciation and sexual conflict. Evolutionary Ecology 19:167–198.']
  • ['Gavrilets S., Rice W. R. 2006. Genetic models of homosexuality: generating testable predictions. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 273:3031–3038.']
  • ['Gavrilets S., Waxman D. 2002. Sympatric speciation by sexual conflict. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 99:10533–10538.']
  • ['Gavrilets S., Arnqvist G., Friberg U. 2001. The evolution of female mate choice by sexual conflict. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 268:531–539.']
  • ['Gordon L. et al. 2011. Expression discordance of monozygotic twins at birth: effect of intrauterine environment and a possible mechanism for fetal programming. Epigenetics 6:579–592.']
  • ['Hagemenas F. C., Kittinger G. W. 1972. The influence of fetal sex on plasma progesterone levels. Endocrinology 91:253–256.']
  • ['Haig D. 1993. Genetic conflicts in human pregnancy. Quarterly Review of Biology 68:495–532.']
  • ['Hall C. M., Jones J. A., Meyer-Bahlburg H. F. L., Dolezal C., Coleman M., Foster P., Price D. A., Clayton P. E. 2004. Behavioral and physical masculinization are related to genotype in girls with congenital adrenal hyperplasia. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism 89:419–424.']
  • ['Hamer D. H., Hu S., Magnuson V. L., Hu N., Pattatucci A. M. 1993. A linkage between DNA markers on the X chromosome and male sexual orientation. Science 261:321–327.']
  • ['Hammond G. L., Leinonen P., Bolton N. J., Vihko R. 1983. Measurement of sex hormone binding globulin in human amniotic fluid: its relationship to protein and testosterone concentrations, and fetal sex. Clinical Endocrinology 18:377–384.']
  • ['Hayashi T. I., Vose M., Gavrilets S. 2007. Genetic differentiation by sexual conflict. Evolution 61:516–529.']
  • ['Heemers H. V., Tindall D. J. 2007. Androgen receptor (AR) coregulators: a diversity of functions converging on and regulating the AR transcriptional complex. Endocrine Reviews 28:778–808.']
  • ["Hemberger M., Dean W., Reik W. 2009. Epigenetic dynamics of stem cells and cell lineage commitment: digging Waddington's canal. Nature Reviews Molecular Cell Biology 10:526–537."]
  • ['Hines M. 2011. Prenatal endocrine influences on sexual orientation and on sexually differentiated childhood behavior. Frontiers in Neuroendocrinology 32:170–182.']
  • ['Hotchkiss A. K., Lambright C. S., Ostby J. S., Parks-Saldutti L., Vandenbergh J. G., Gray L. E., Jr. 2007. Prenatal testosterone exposure permanently masculinizes anogenital distance, nipple development, and reproductive tract morphology in female Sprague-Dawley rats. Toxicological Sciences 96:335–345.']
  • ['Iemmola F., Camperio-Ciani A. 2009. New evidence of genetic factors influencing sexual orientation in men: female fecundity increase in the maternal line. Archives of Sexual Behavior 38:393–399.']
  • ['Imperato-McGinley J., Peterson R. E., Stoller R., Goodwin W. E. 1979. Male pseudohermaphroditism secondary to 17 β-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase deficiency: gender role change with puberty. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism 49:391–395.']
  • ['Jensen M. S., Toft G., Thulstrup A. M., Henriksen T. B., Olsen J., Christensen K., Bonde J. P. 2010. Cryptorchidism concordance in monozygotic and dizygotic twin brothers, full brothers, and half-brothers. Fertility and Sterility 93:124–129.']
  • ['Kalfa N., Philibert P., Baskin L. S., Sultan C. 2011. Hypospadias: interactions between environment and genetics. Molecular and Cellular Endocrinology 335:89–95.']
  • ['Kapur P., Pereira B. M. J., Wuttke W., Jarry H. 2009. Androgenic action of Tinospora cordifolia ethanolic extract in prostate cancer cell line LNCaP. Phytomedicine 16:679–682.']
  • ['King M., Green J., Osborn D. P. J., Arkell J., Hetherton J., Pereira E. 2005. Family size in white gay and heterosexual men. Archives of Sexual Behavior 34:117–122.']
  • ['Kirk K. M., Bailey J. M., Dunne M. P., Martin N. G. 2000. Measurement models for sexual orientation in a community twin sample. Behavior Genetics 30:345–356.']
  • ['Långström N., Rahman Q., Carlström E., Lichtenstein P. 2010. Genetic and environmental effects on same-sex sexual behavior: a population study of twins in Sweden. Archives of Sexual Behavior 39:75–80.']
  • ['Latch E. K., Amann R. P., Jacobson J. P., Rhodes O. E., Jr. 2008. Competing hypotheses for the etiology of cryptorchidism in Sitka black-tailed deer: an evaluation of evolutionary alternatives. Animal Conservation 11:234–246.']
  • ['Meyer-Bahlburg H. F. L. 1993. Psychobiologic research on homosexuality. Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Clinics of North America 2:489–500.']
  • ['Mikkelsen T. S. et al. 2007. Genome-wide maps of chromatin state in pluripotent and lineage-committed cells. Nature 448:553–560.']
  • ['Miller P. M., Gavrilets S., Rice W. R. 2006. Sexual conflict via maternal-effect genes in ZW species. Science 312:73.']
  • ['Morgan C. P., Bale T. L. 2011. Early prenatal stress epigenetically programs dysmasculinization in second-generation offspring via the paternal linage. Journal of Neuroscience 31:11784–11755.']
  • ['Morgan D. K., Whitelaw E. 2008. The case for transgenerational epigenetic inheritance in humans. Mammalian Genome 19:394–397.']
  • ['New M. I. 2004. An update of congenital adrenal hyperplasia. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1038:14–43.']
  • ['Ngun T. C., Ghahramani N., Sánchez F. J., Bocklandt S., Vilain E. 2011. The genetics of sex differences in brain and behavior. Frontiers in Neuroendocrinology 32:227–246.']
  • ['Ollikainen M. et al. 2010. DNA methylation analysis of multiple tissues from newborn twins reveals both genetic and intrauterine components to variation in the human neonatal epigenome. Human Molecular Genetics 19:4176–4188.']
  • ['Ostby J., Monosson E., Kelce W. R., Gray L. E., Jr. 1999. Environmental antiandrogens: low doses of the fungicide vinclozolin alter sexual differentiation of the male rat. Toxicology and Industrial Health 15:48–64.']
  • ['Parker G. A. 1979. Sexual selection and sexual conflict. Pages 123–166 in Sexual Selection and Reproductive Competition in Insects, edited by M. S. Blum and N. A. Blum. New York: Academic Press.']
  • ['Parker G. A., Partridge L. 1998. Sexual conflict and speciation. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society London B: Biological Sciences 353:261–274.']
  • ['Partridge L., Hurst L. D. 1998. Sex and conflict. Science 281:2003–2008.']
  • ['Pattatucci A. M. L., Hamer D. H. 1995. Development and familiality of sexual orientation in females. Behavior Genetics 25:407–420.']
  • ['Perera D. M. D., McGarrigle H. H. G., Lawrence D. M., Lucas M. 1987. Amniotic fluid testosterone and testosterone glucuronide levels in the determination of foetal sex. Journal of Steroid Biochemistry 26:273–277.']
  • ['Phoenix C. H., Goy R. W., Gerall A. A., Young W. C. 1959. Organizing action of prenatally administered testosterone propionate on the tissues mediating mating behavior in the female guinea pig. Endocrinology 65:369–382.']
  • ['Rahman Q., Collins A., Morrison M., Orrells J. C., Cadinouche K., Greenfield S., Begum S. 2008. Maternal inheritance and familial fecundity factors in male homosexuality. Archives of Sexual Behavior 37:962–969.']
  • ['Ramagopalan S. V., Dyment D. A., Handunnetthi L., Rice G. P., Ebers G. C. 2010. A genome-wide scan of male sexual orientation. Journal of Human Genetics 55:131–132.']
  • ['Reiner W. G., Gearhart J. P. 2004. Discordant sexual identity in some genetic males with cloacal exstrophy assigned to female sex at birth. New England Journal of Medicine 350:333–341.']
  • ['Rey R. A., Grinspon R. P. 2011. Normal male sexual differentiation and aetiology of disorders of sex development. Best Practice & Research Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism 25:221–238.']
  • ['Reyes F. I., Boroditsky R. S., Winter J. S. D., Faiman C. 1974. Studies on human sexual development. II. Fetal and maternal serum gonadotropin and sex steroid concentrations. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism 38:612–617.']
  • ['Rice W. R. 1996. Sexually antagonistic male adaptation triggered by experimental arrest of female evolution. Nature 381:232–234.']
  • ['Rice W. R., Holland B. 1997. The enemies within: intergenomic conflict, interlocus contest evolution (ICE), and the intraspecific Red Queen. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 41:1–10.']
  • ['Rice W. R., Gavrilets S., Friberg U. 2008. Sexually antagonistic “zygotic drive” of the sex chromosomes. PLoS Genetics 4:e1000313.']
  • ['Rice W. R., Gavrilets S., Friberg U. 2009. Sexually antagonistic chromosomal cuckoos. Biology Letters 5:686–688.']
  • ['Rice W. R., Gavrilets S., Friberg U. 2010. The evolution of sex-specific grandparental harm. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 277:2727–2735.']
  • ['Savic I., Lindström P. 2008. PET and MRI show differences in cerebral asymmetry and functional connectivity between homo- and heterosexual subjects. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 105:9403–9408.']
  • ['Sax L. 2002. How common is intersex? A response to Anne Fausto-Sterling. Journal of Sex Research 39:174–178.']
  • ['Schwartz G., Kim R. M., Kolundzija A. B., Rieger G., Sanders A. R. 2010. Biodemographic and physical correlates of sexual orientation in men. Archives of Sexual Behavior 39:93–109.']
  • ['Slatkin M. 2009. Epigenetic inheritance and the missing heritability problem. Genetics 182:845–850.']
  • ['Speiser P. W., White P. C. 2003. Congenital adrenal hyperplasia. New England Journal of Medicine 349:776–788.']
  • ['Swaab D. F. 2007. Sexual differentiation of the brain and behavior. Best Practice & Research Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism 21:431–444.']
  • ['Thornton J., Zehr J. L., Loose M. D. 2009. Effects of prenatal androgens on rhesus monkeys: a model system to explore the organizational hypothesis in primates. Hormones and Behavior 55:633–645.']
  • ['Trakakis E., Loghis C., Kassanos D. 2009. Congenital adrenal hyperplasia because of 21-hydroxylase deficiency. A genetic disorder of interest to obstetricians and gynecologists. Obstetrical & Gynecological Survey 64:177–189.']
  • ["Travison T. G., Araujo A. B., O'Donnell A. B., Kupelian V., McKinlay J. B. 2007. A population-level decline in serum testosterone levels in American men. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism 92:196–202."]
  • ['van Beijsterveldt C. E. M., Hudziak J. J., Boomsma D. I. 2006. Genetic and environmental influences on cross-gender behavior and relation to behavior problems: a study of Dutch twins at ages 7 and 10 years. Archives of Sexual Behavior 35:647–658.']
  • ['Waddington C. H. 1942. Canalization of development and the inheritance of acquired characters. Nature 150:563–565.']
  • ['Weidner I. S., Moller H., Jensen T. K., Skakkebaek N. E. 1999. Risk factors for cryptorchidism and hypospadias. Journal of Urology 161:1606–1609.']
  • ['Weisz J., Ward I. L. 1980. Plasma testosterone and progesterone titers of pregnant rats, their male and female fetuses, and neonatal offspring. Endocrinology 106:306–316.']
  • ['Wijchers P. J., Festenstein R. J. 2011. Epigenetic regulation of autosomal gene expression by sex chromosomes. Trends in Genetics 27:132–140.']
  • ['Wilson E. O. 1975. Sociobiology: The New Synthesis. Cambridge (Massachusetts): Harvard University Press.']
  • ['Wilson J. D., George F. W., Griffin J. E. 1981. The hormonal control of sexual development. Science 211:1278–1284.']
  • ['Wilson J. D., Griffin J. E., Russell D. W. 1993. Steroid 5α-reductase 2 deficiency. Endocrine Reviews 14:577–593.']
  • ['Wisniewski A. B., Kirk K. D., Copeland K. C. 2008. Long-term psychosexual development in genetic males affected by disorders of sex development (46,XY DSD) reared male or female. Current Pediatric Reviews 4:243–249.']
  • ['Wong A. H. C., Gottesman I. I., Petronis A. 2005. Phenotypic differences in genetically identical organisms: the epigenetic perspective. Human Molecular Genetics 14:R11–R18.']
  • ['Wright A. S., Thomas L. N., Douglas R. C., Lazier C. B., Rittmaster R. S. 1996. Relative potency of testosterone and dihydrotestosterone in preventing atrophy and apoptosis in the prostate of the castrated rat. Journal of Clinical Investigation 98:2558–2563.']
  • ['Zamansoltani F., Nassiri-Asl M., Sarookhani M.-R., Jahani-Hashemi H., Zangivand A.-A. 2009. Antiandrogenic activities of Glycyrrhiza glabra in male rats. International Journal of Andrology 32:417–422.']