Access

You are not currently logged in.

Access your personal account or get JSTOR access through your library or other institution:

login

Log in to your personal account or through your institution.

The States as Laboratories of Statutory Interpretation: Methodological Consensus and the New Modified Textualism

ABBE R. GLUCK
The Yale Law Journal
Vol. 119, No. 8 (JUNE 2010), pp. 1750-1862
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/25681957
Page Count: 113
  • Subscribe ($19.50)
  • Cite this Item
The States as Laboratories of Statutory Interpretation: Methodological Consensus and the New Modified Textualism
Preview not available

Abstract

This Article offers the first close study of statutory interpretation in several state courts of last resort. While academics have spent the past decade speculating about the "death of textualism," the utility of legislated rules of interpretation, and the capacity of judges to agree on a single set of interpretive rules, state courts, as it turns out, have been engaging in real-world experiments in precisely these areas. Several state courts have articulated governing interpretive regimes for all statutory questions. Methodological stare decisis—the practice of giving precedential effect to judicial statements about methodology—is generally absent from federal statutory interpretation, but appears to be a common feature of some states' statutory case law. Every state legislature in the nation has enacted certain rules of interpretation, which some state courts are, in an unexpected twist, flouting. And, far from textualism being "dead," what emerges from these state cases is a surprisingly strong consensus methodology—what this Article terms "modified textualism"—a theory that shares textualism's core components but has broader potential appeal. These state developments offer a powerful counter-paradigm to that of the U.S. Supreme Court, where persistent interpretive divides and a refusal to treat methodological statements as precedential have made interpretive consensus seem impossible. They also highlight that, for all the energy that the statutory interpretation wars have consumed, the legal status of methodology itself—whether it is "law" or something "less"—remains entirely unresolved.

Page Thumbnails

  • Thumbnail: Page 
1750
    1750
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1751
    1751
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1752
    1752
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1753
    1753
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1754
    1754
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1755
    1755
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1756
    1756
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1757
    1757
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1758
    1758
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1759
    1759
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1760
    1760
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1761
    1761
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1762
    1762
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1763
    1763
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1764
    1764
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1765
    1765
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1766
    1766
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1767
    1767
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1768
    1768
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1769
    1769
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1770
    1770
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1771
    1771
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1772
    1772
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1773
    1773
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1774
    1774
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1775
    1775
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1776
    1776
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1777
    1777
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1778
    1778
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1779
    1779
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1780
    1780
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1781
    1781
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1782
    1782
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1783
    1783
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1784
    1784
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1785
    1785
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1786
    1786
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1787
    1787
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1788
    1788
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1789
    1789
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1790
    1790
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1791
    1791
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1792
    1792
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1793
    1793
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1794
    1794
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1795
    1795
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1796
    1796
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1797
    1797
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1798
    1798
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1799
    1799
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1800
    1800
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1801
    1801
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1802
    1802
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1803
    1803
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1804
    1804
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1805
    1805
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1806
    1806
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1807
    1807
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1808
    1808
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1809
    1809
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1810
    1810
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1811
    1811
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1812
    1812
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1813
    1813
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1814
    1814
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1815
    1815
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1816
    1816
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1817
    1817
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1818
    1818
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1819
    1819
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1820
    1820
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1821
    1821
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1822
    1822
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1823
    1823
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1824
    1824
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1825
    1825
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1826
    1826
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1827
    1827
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1828
    1828
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1829
    1829
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1830
    1830
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1831
    1831
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1832
    1832
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1833
    1833
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1834
    1834
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1835
    1835
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1836
    1836
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1837
    1837
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1838
    1838
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1839
    1839
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1840
    1840
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1841
    1841
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1842
    1842
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1843
    1843
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1844
    1844
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1845
    1845
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1846
    1846
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1847
    1847
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1848
    1848
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1849
    1849
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1850
    1850
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1851
    1851
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1852
    1852
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1853
    1853
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1854
    1854
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1855
    1855
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1856
    1856
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1857
    1857
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1858
    1858
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1859
    1859
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1860
    1860
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1861
    1861
  • Thumbnail: Page 
1862
    1862