Access

You are not currently logged in.

Access your personal account or get JSTOR access through your library or other institution:

login

Log in to your personal account or through your institution.

Specific Performance of Contracts. Defence of Lack of Mutuality. Fifth Paper. The Statute of Frauds

William Draper Lewis
The American Law Register (1898-1907)
Vol. 49, No. 10, Volume 40 New Series (Oct., 1901), pp. 559-579
DOI: 10.2307/3306904
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/3306904
Page Count: 21
Subjects: Law
Find more content in these subjects: Law
  • Download PDF
  • Add to My Lists
  • Cite this Item
We're having trouble loading this content. Download PDF instead.

Notes and References

This item contains 54 references.

[Footnotes]
  • 1
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • 29 Car. II c. 3
    • 3 Stat. at Lar., p. 385
  • 3
    Hawkins v. Holmes, i P. Wms. 770, I72I.
  • 4
    2 Ch. Cas. i64, i684.
  • 5
    This reference contains 3 citations:
    • First Paper, May number, supra, page 270 et seq.
    • 1 Eq. Cas. Abr., p. 2I sec. I0
    • Cape- hart v. Hale, 6 W. Va. 547, i873, pp. 55I-555
  • 6
    5 Vin. Abr. 527, I707.
  • 7
    2 Bing. N. C. 735, page 743.
  • 8
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • 2 Eq. Cas. Abr. 32, p1. 44, I736.
    • Backhouse v. Mohun in a note to 3 Swanst., page 434.
  • 9
    This reference contains 3 citations:
    • Child v. Comber, 3 Swanst. 423 note, I723
    • dicta in Hawkins v. Holmes, i P. Win. 770, I72I.
    • Owen v. Davies, i Ves. Sr. 82, I747
  • 10
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • Seton v. Slade, 7 Ves. 265, i802
    • Fowle v. Freemen, g Ves. 35I, i804.
  • 11
    Allen v. Bennet, 3 Taunt. i69.
  • 12
    i Sch. & Lef. I3, I802.
  • 13
    First Paper, May number, supra, page 270.
  • 15
    I Ves. 583, I805, page 592.
  • 16
    Huddleston v. Briscoe was rendered December 20, i8o5
  • 17
    Stratford v. Bosworth, 2 Ves. & B. 34I, i8I3, page 345.
  • 18
    2 Ball & B. 363, i8I3, page 370.
  • 19
    3 Ves. & B. I87, I8I4, page I92.
  • 20
    2 J. & W. 413.
  • 24
    This reference contains 7 citations:
    • Boys v. Ayerst, 6 Mad. 3i6, I822, dicta.
    • Flight v. Balland, 4 Rus. 298, I828, page 30I, dicta
    • Palmer v. Scott, i R. & M. 391, 1830
    • Field v. Boland, i D. & Wa. 37, 1837, Irish
    • Sutherland v. Briggs, i Hare, 26, 184I, dicta
    • Semble, Dowell v. Dew, Morgan v. Halford, i Sm. & Giff. ioi, i852, dicta.
    • Gaskarth v. Lord Lowther, I2 Ves. I07, I805.
  • 25
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • 4 Rus. 298, i828.
    • First Paper, May number, supra, page 273.
  • 26
    Third Paper, August number, supra, page 448.
  • 27
    i Johns. Ch. 273 (N. Y.), i8I4, page 282.
  • 28
    i Johns. Ch. 370 (N. Y.) i8I5, pages 373 and 374.
  • 29
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • one 5 Bos. & P. (i N. S.) 252, i805
    • Allen v. Bennett, 3 Taun. i6g, i8io
  • 30
    I4 Johns, 484 (N. Y.), I8I7.
  • 32
    This reference contains 12 citations:
    • Getchell v. Jewett, 4 Green, 350 (Me.) i826, pages 366, 367
    • M'Crea v. Purmort, i6 Wend. 460 (N. Y.), i836, page 465
    • Old Colony R. R. v. Evans, 6 Gray, 25 (Mass.) i856, pages 3I, 32 and 33
    • Farwell v. Lowther, i8 Ill. 252, i857, page 255
    • Esmay v. Gorton, i8 Ill. 483, i857, page 486
    • Chambers v. Alabama Iron Co., 67 Ala. 353, i88o
    • Carskaddon v. Kennedy, 40 N. J. Eq. 259, i885
    • Miller v. Cameron, I5 Atl. 845 (N. J.), i888.
    • Perkins v. Hadsell, 50 Ill. 2i6, i869, page 220
    • Capehart v. Hale, 6 W. Va. 547, i873
    • Marqueze v. Caldwell, 48 Miss. 23, i873
    • Lee v. Dozier, 40 Miss. 48i, i865.
  • 33
    This reference contains 6 citations:
    • Mirzell v. Burnett, 4 Jones 249 (N. C.), I857
    • Ballard v. Walker, 3 Johns, 6o (N. Y.) i802
    • Hanson v. Barnes, 3 Gill & John- son, 359 (Md.), I83I
    • Kizer v. Locke, g Ala. 269, I846
    • Mirzell v. Barnett, 4 Jones 249 (N. C.), I857
    • Luckett v. Williamson, 37 Mo. 388, i866.
  • 34
    6 Me. 92, i839.
  • 35
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • Shirley v. Shirley, 7 Black, 452 (Ind.), i845
    • Moses v. McClain, 2 S. 74I (Ala.), i887.
  • 36
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • Martin v. Grimes, 88 Mo. 478, i885.
    • McPherson v.Fargo, 74 N. W. I057 (S. D.), i898
  • 37
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • 43 Cal. 458, i872, page 465
    • Cooper v. Penna.,, 2i Cal. 403, i863.
  • 38
    4 R. I. 14, I855.
  • 39
    Estes v. Furlong, 59 Ill. 298, i87I, page 302.
  • 40
    This reference contains 12 citations:
    • Jones v. Robbins, 29 Me. 35I, i849
    • Plunkett v. The Methodist Soc., 3 Cush. 56i (Mass.), I849
    • Parker v. Perkins, 8 Cush. 3I8 (Mass.), I85I
    • Murphy v. Marland, Ib. 573, 1851
    • Johnson v. Dodge, I7 Ill. 433, I856
    • Barnard v. Lee, 97 Mass. 92, i867
    • Ewins v. Gordon, 49 N. H. 444, I870
    • Howland v. Bradley, 38 N. J. Eq. 288, I844
    • Laning v. Cole, 4 N. J. Eq. 229, i842
    • Wilks v. Georgia, Pacific R. R., 79 Ala. i8o, i885
    • Linn v. McLean, 85 Ala. 250, i887, dicta
    • Ross v. Parks, 93 Ala. I53, i89o.
  • 42
    Third Paper, August number, supra, 452.
  • 43
    4 Gill. 472, i846.
  • 44
    i Md. Ch. I3, I847.
  • 45
    2 Md. Ch. 40I.
  • 46
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • Rider v. Gray, io Md. 282, I856
    • Third Paper, August number, supra, page 453.
  • 47
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • Stat. at Large, Part II, Chap. vii, title I, sec. 8.
    • N. Y. Rev. Stat., Vol. 5, page 3588, ? 224
  • 49
    Frazer v. Ford, 2 Head. 464, i859.
  • 50
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • Semble Bigler v. Baker, 38 N. W. I026 (Neb.), i894.
    • Gartrell v. Stafford, I2 Neb. 545, i882.
  • 51
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • Champlin v. Parrish, ii Paige, 408 (N. Y. Ch.), i834.
    • McWhorter v. McMahan, io Paige, 393 (N. Y. Ch.), i842.
  • 53
    This reference contains 3 citations:
    • I W. & S. 554 (Pa.), i84I.
    • Irvine v. Bull, 4 Watts, 287 (Pa.), i835
    • Ellet v. Paxson, 2 W. & S. 4i8, i84I.
  • 56
    I Pars. Eq. Cas. 78 (Pa.) i844.
  • 58
    io Watts. 387 (Pa.) i840.
  • 60
    Patton v. Develin, 2 Phila. I03 (Pa.) i856.
  • 61
    This reference contains 7 citations:
    • M'Farson's App., iI Pa. 503, i849
    • Shoofstall v. Adams, 2 Grant, 209, i858
    • Tripp v. Bishop, 56 Pa. 424, i867
    • Johnston v. Cowan, 59 Pa. 275, i868
    • Smith's App., 69 Pa. 474, i871
    • Cadwalader's App., 8i Pa. 194, i876, dicta
    • Swiss- helm v. The Swissvale Laundry Co., 95 Pa. 367, i88o
  • 62
    This reference contains 6 citations:
    • Meason v. Kaine, 63 Pa. 335, i869.
    • Sands v. Arthur, 84 Pa. 479 i877
    • Sausser v. Steinmetz, 88 Pa. 324
    • Swisshelm v. The Swiss- vale Laundry Co., 95 Pa. 367, i88o.
    • Bodine v. Glading, 2i Pa. 50, i853.
    • Third Paper, August number, supra, page 453, et seq.
  • 63
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • Corson v. Mulvaney, 49 Pa. 88, i865
    • Third Paper, August number, supra, page 455.
  • 64
    Reed, Statute of Frauds, sec. 367
  • 65
    This reference contains 17 citations:
    • Saun- derson v. Jackson, 2 Bos.
    • Egerton v. Matthews, 6 East. 307, 1805.
    • Champion v. Plummer, 5 Bos. and Put. 252
    • supra, note 29
    • Alber v. Bennet, 3 Taun, i69, i8io
    • Liverpool Borough Bank v. Eccles, 4 H. & N. I37, i859.
    • Douglass v. Spears, 2 Nott & McCord, 207 (S. C.) i8ig
    • Barstow v. Gray, 3 Greenleaf, 409 (Me.) i825, dicta
    • Russell v. Nicoll, 3 Wend. II7 (N. Y.) i829
    • Davis v. Shields, 26 Wend. 34I (N. Y.) i84I
    • Smith v. Smith, 8 Blackford, 209 (Ind.) i847
    • Cummings v. Dennett, 26 Me. 397, i847, dicta
    • Linton v. Williams, 25 Ga. 39I, I858
    • Morin v. Martz, 13 Minn, i9i, i868
    • Wemple v. Knopf, I5 Minn. 44o, i870, dicta
    • Brooklyn Oil Refinery v. Brown, 38 How. Prac. 444, i870.
    • infra
  • 66
    Sand. S. C. R. (N. Y.) 272, i849.
  • 67
    I Abb. Pr. N. S. 300, I (N. Y.) i865.