Access

You are not currently logged in.

Access your personal account or get JSTOR access through your library or other institution:

login

Log in to your personal account or through your institution.

The Rule in Rylands v. Fletcher. Part I

Francis H. Bohlen
University of Pennsylvania Law Review and American Law Register
Vol. 59, No. 5, Volume 50 New Series (Feb., 1911), pp. 298-326
DOI: 10.2307/3307445
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/3307445
Page Count: 29
Subjects: Law
  • Download PDF
  • Add to My Lists
  • Cite this Item
The Rule in Rylands v. Fletcher. Part I
We're having trouble loading this content. Download PDF instead.

Notes and References

This item contains 25 references.

[Footnotes]
  • 1
    This reference contains 3 citations:
    • As Fletcher v. Rylands, in the Court of Exchccquer, 3 H. & C. 774 (1865).
    • Excchccqtier Chamnber, L. R. X Ex. 265 (1866),
    • Rylands v. Fletcher in the House of Lords, L. R. 3 H. L (E & I. App.) 33o (i8M).
  • 2
    This reference contains 5 citations:
    • Bower v. Peate, L. R. i Q. B. D. 321 (t876);
    • Angus v. Daltoni, L. R. 6 A. C. 740 (i88i);
    • Hughes v. Percival, L. R. 8 A. C. 443 (1883),
    • Halliday v. Tele- phone Co., L R. 1899, 1 Q. B. 392,
    • Bohlen's Cases on Torts, pp. 595 to 636.
  • 3
    This reference contains 10 citations:
    • L- R. i Exch.. p. 278.
    • Tenanit v. Goldwin, i Salk. 21. 360, 2 Ld. lRaym.
    • ioSg, 6 Mod. 311,
    • z Salk., p. 21.
    • Yillding v. Fay Moor, 355- (1596),
    • 6 U. of P. L R., pp. 223-224,
    • note ig, p.2 32,
    • Bell v. Twentyman, 1 A. & E. (N. S.) 766 (1841).
    • Tonawanda R. R. v. Muinger, 5 Denio (N. Y.) 2SS (1848), i855,
    • Erd- man v. Gottshall, 9 Pa. Supl). 295 (899).
  • 6
    Brown v. Collins, S3 N. H. 442 (1873), p. 448
  • 7
    3 H. & C;
  • 8
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • DOe. C. J.. it' PlrouIN V. V('CMIn. 53 N. II.. 1p. 44Q
    • Beasley, C. J.. ill M:rslmll V. \WIWo(d, 3 3 ' N. J. L. 339 (0876), p. 341,
  • 10
    Brown v. Kensdall, 6 Cusli. (CMass.) 29 (185o),
  • 11
    This reference contains 4 citations:
    • Weaver v. Wardl. Hobart, 1,4 ( i66):
    • Dickenson v. WVatson, T. Jones, 205. ( Si621.
    • St;miley v. Powcll, L R. i&)i ;
    • i Q. B. 86o, arc the IE:nglish cases uIsutally cited.
  • 12
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • Stanley v. Powell, L R. t891;
    • X Q. B. 6
  • 15
    As was hel(d in Griffith v, Lewis, 17 Mo. App. 6o5 (i88S).
  • 16
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • Bell v. Twentyman, i A. & E. (N. S.) 766 (1841),
    • Fletcher v. Rylands, L R. 1 Ex., p. 24.
  • 17
    This reference contains 14 citations:
    • Hay v. Cohoes Co., 2 N. Y. 159 (1&49),
    • lBay v. Scott, 3 Md1. 431 (1853);
    • R. R. v. Eagles, 9 Colo. 544 ('886);
    • Klepsech v. Donald, 4 Wash. 436 (t8g2),
    • MIason, J., ill Bay v. Scott, and(l Alvey, J., in Lawson v. Price, 45 Md. 123 (i876).
    • St. Peter v. Denlison, 58 N. Y. 416 (1874),
    • Dunham v. Sullivan, i6i N. Y. 2W (igoo),
    • Turuer v. Degront Mclecan Co., go N. Y. Supp. 948 (1904).
    • Booth v. R. R., i4o N. Y. 267 (X893),
    • French v. Vix, 143 N. Y. go (1894).
    • Simon v. Henry, 62 N. J. L. 486 (189);
    • Fox v. Borkey, 126 Pa. I64 (i889), semble.
    • WUheeler v. Norton, 86 N. Y. iog5 (1904),
    • The lFitz Simons & Conwell Co. v. Braun1 & Fitts, igg 111. 390Q
  • 18
    This reference contains 6 citations:
    • Pottstown Gas Co. v. Murphy, 39 Pa. 257 (i861),
    • p. o6o,
    • Ottawa Gas Co. v. Graham, 28 111. 74 (1862).
    • Kinnaird v. Stand(lardi Oil Co.. &) Ky. 468 (189o),
    • Pixley v. Clark, 35 N. Y. s52 (t866),
    • Hay v. Cohoes, supra, note 17,
  • 19
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • BI. Com. 431.
    • Filliter v. Pliippard, 11 Q. B. (A. & E, N. S.) 347.
  • 20
    This reference contains 8 citations:
    • Clark v. Foot, 8 John (N. Y.), 42i (a8rr);
    • Lehigh Bridge Co. v. Lehigh Nav. Co., 4 Rawle, 9 (1833);
    • Gibson, C. J., pp. 24-25;
    • Bachelder v. Heagan, i8 Me. 32 (1840);
    • Tourtellot v. Rosebrook, xI Met. (52 MIass.) 460 (1846);
    • Lahn v. Roberts. 8 Wis. 255 (1859);
    • P. C & St. L R. R. v. Culver, 60 Ind. 469;
    • Johnson v. Veneman, 75 Kans. 278 (1907).
  • 21
    This reference contains 9 citations:
    • Delaney v. Erickson, 1o Neb. 492 (i88o);
    • Studwell v. Ritch, 14 Conn. 292 (1841);
    • Wagner v. Bissell, 3 Iowa, 396 (1856);
    • Seeley v. Peters, 5 Gilm (Ill.), 130 ('848);
    • Little Rock, etc., R. R. v. Finley, 37 Ark. 562 (1881);
    • Morris v. Foraker, S Colo. 425 (i88o);
    • Sprague v. R R., 6 Dak. 86 (i886);
    • R. R. v. Geiger, 21 Fla. 669 (i886);
    • Buford v. Houtz, 133 U. S. 32o (189o), semble.
  • 22
    This reference contains 7 citations:
    • Livingston v. Adams, 8 Cowen (N. Y.), 175 (1828);
    • Lapham v. Curtis, 5 Vt. 371 (1833);
    • Shrewsbury v. Smith, 12 Cush. (66 Mlass.) i77 (M8s3);
    • Todd v. Cockhill. 17 Cal. 97 (1860);
    • Everett v. Hydraulic Flume Co., 23 CaL 225 (I863);
    • Kug v. Miles City Irrigating Co., i6 Mont. 463 (*8g5),
    • Brennan Co. v. Cumberland Co., 15 L R. A. (N. S.) 54S.
  • Losee v. Buchanan, Si N. Y. 476 (1873),
  • 26
    This reference contains 8 citations:
    • Baird v. Williamson, 15 C. B. (N. S.) 376 (1863),
    • Wtestminster Coal Co. v. Clayton, 36 L. J.. Ch. 476 (1867),
    • West Cumberland Iron Co. v. Kenyon. L. R., ix Ch. Div. 782 (X879),
    • John Young & Co. v. Bankier, L. R. 1893. A. C. 691,
    • Fry, J., Atty. Gen. v. Toinline, L R., 12 Ch. Div., p. 230 (1879).
    • Brett M. R. Whalley v. Ry., L. R., 13 Q. B. D. 131 (1T884). p. 141.
    • Clerk and Londell on Torts, 2nd Ed., p. 367, n. d.;
    • Fry, J., Atty. Gen. v. Tomline, supra, p. 230,
  • 27
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • notes 30
    • 31.
  • 28
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • Bramwell, B., in Bamfordt v. Tturiley, 3 B. & S. 66 (X862), says, p. 83:
    • Dodderidge, J., in Jones v. Powell, Palmer, S35 (1628), p. .37:
  • 29
    Bramwell, B., in Bamford v. Turney, p. 84
  • 30
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • Jones v. Powell, Palmer, 535 (1627),
    • "Hide," C. J., says, p. 538:
  • 31
    This reference contains 5 citations:
    • alvin v. Brancepeth Coal Co., L R., g Ch. App. 705 (1874),
    • James, L J., pp. 709-710,
    • St. Helens Smelting v. Tipping, iI H. L C 642 (i865),
    • Westbury, L C. 750.
    • Dodderidge, J., in Jones T. Powell, Palmer, 536, p. 537:
  • 32
    St. Helens Smelting Co. v. Tipping, i H. L C 64I.