Access

You are not currently logged in.

Access your personal account or get JSTOR access through your library or other institution:

login

Log in to your personal account or through your institution.

Interests Created by Grants of Coal Apart from the Surface

W. R. V.
The Yale Law Journal
Vol. 31, No. 7 (May, 1922), pp. 747-754
DOI: 10.2307/788363
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/788363
Page Count: 8
Subjects: Law
Find more content in these subjects: Law
  • Download PDF
  • Add to My Lists
  • Cite this Item
We're having trouble loading this content. Download PDF instead.

Notes and References

This item contains 42 references.

[Footnotes]
  • 1
    This reference contains 5 citations:
    • Duke of Hamilton v. Graham (i87i, H. L.) L. R. 2 Sc. App. Cas. i66
    • Wester- man v. Penn. Salt Mfg. Co. (i9i8) 260 Pa. I40, I03 Atl. 539
    • 3Lindley, Mines (3d ed. 1914) sec. 812
    • MacSwinney, Mines (3d ed. 1907) 42
    • ITiffany, Real Property (1920 ed.) 867.
  • 2
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • Kinder v. La Salle County Coal Co. (I92I, Ill.) I33 N. E. 772.
    • Stoughton v. Leigh (i8o8, K. B.) I Taunt. 402.
  • 3
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • Graciosa Oil Co. v. Santa Barbara (i909) I55 Calif. i40, 99 Pac. 483
    • Con- solidated Coal Co. v. Baker (i89i) I35 Ill. 545, 26 N. E. 65I.
  • 4
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • Caldwell v. Fulton (0858) 3I Pa. 475
    • Marble Co. v. Ripley (i870, U. S.) IO Wall. 339.
  • 5
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • Batten Pool v. Kennedy [i907] I Ch. 256
    • Whitaker v. Brown (i863) 46 Pa. I97.
  • 6
    Lee v. Buingardner (i889) 86 Va. 3I5, I0 S. E. 3.
  • 7
    Kinder v. La Salle County Coal Co., supra note 2.
  • 8
    This reference contains 3 citations:
    • Renfro v. Hanon (I92I) 297 Ill. 353, I30 N. E. 740
    • Armstrong v. Caldwell (i866) 53 Pa. 284
    • Gill v. Fletcher (i906) 74 Ohio St. 295, 78 N. E. 433.
  • 9
    This reference contains 3 citations:
    • Pardee v. Murray (i882) 4 Mont. 234, 2 Pac. i6
    • Armstrong v. Caldwell, supra note 8; Scott v. Laws (i9i9) i85 Ky. 440, 2I5 S. W. 8i.
    • McBurney v. Glenmary Coal & Coke Co. (I909) I2I Tenn. 275, ii8 S. W. 694.
  • 10
    Attebery v. Blair (I910) 244 Ill. 363, 9I N. E. 475.
  • 11
    This reference contains 9 citations:
    • Proud v. Bates (i865) 34 L. J. Ch. 4o6
    • Duke of Hamilton v. Graham, supra note 1
    • Batten Pool v. Kennedy, supra note 5
    • Lillibridge v. Lackawanna Coal Co. (I89I) I43 Pa. 293, 22 Atl. I035
    • Westerman v. Penn. Salt Mfg. Co., supra note 1
    • Attebery v. Blair, supra note 10
    • Madison v. Garfield Coal Co. (I9OI) I I4 Iowa, 56, 86 N. W. 4I
    • Lindley, op. cit. sec. 813a
    • MacSwinney, op. cit. 79
  • 12
    This reference contains 6 citations:
    • Chartiers Block Coal Co. v. Mellon (I893) 152 Pa. 286, 25 Atl. 597
    • Webber v. Vogel (I893) I59 Pa. 235, 28 AtI. 226
    • Ramsay v. Blair (i876, H. L.) L. R. I App. Cas. 70I
    • Lord Chelmsford in Duke of Hamilton v. Graham, supra note 1, at pp. 171, 172, 175, 176.
    • Eardley v. Granville (I876) L. R. 3 Ch. Div. 826
    • Bowser v. Maclean (i86o, Ch.) 2 De G. F. & J. 4I5.
  • 13
    (I92O) I28 Va. 383, I05 S. E. II7.
  • 14
    This reference contains 3 citations:
    • Chartiers Block Coal Co. v. Mellon, supra note 12
    • Webber v. Vogel (I899) i8g Pa. I56, 42 Atl. 4
    • McBurney v. Glenmary Coal and Coke Co., supra note 9.
  • 15
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • supra note 14
    • infra note 17
  • 16
    Lillibridge v. Lacka- wanna Coal Co., supra note 11.
  • 17
    This reference contains 5 citations:
    • Lillibridge v. Lackawanna Coal Co., supra note 11
    • Whitaker v. Brown, supra note 5
    • Schobert v. Pittsburgh Coal & Mining Co. (19I2) 254 Ill. 474, 98 N. E. 945
    • Webber v. Vogel cases [ (i893) 159 Pa. 235, 28 Atl. 226
    • (i899) I89 Pa. I56, 42 Atl. 4]
  • 18
    Westerman v. Penn. Salt Mfg. Co., supra note 1
  • 19
    This reference contains 4 citations:
    • Coke, Littleton, 13b
    • Church of Latter Day Saints v. United States (i889) 136 U. S. I, Io Sup. Ct. 792
    • First Universalist Soc. v. Bolland (I892) I55 Mass. 17I, 29 N. E. 524
    • 1 Tiffany, op. cit. 334
  • 20
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • Walsingharnt's Case (I573, Exch.) Plowd. 552, 557
    • Challis, Real Property (3d ed. 1911) 262.
  • 21
    (ixio) 67 W. Va. 589, 6o8, 69 S. E. 195, 203.
  • 22
    This reference contains 6 citations:
    • Doe v. Wood (i8g9, K. B.) 2 Barn. & Ald. 724, 739
    • In re Haven Gold Mining Co. (i882, C. A.) L. R. 20 Ch. Div. 15I
    • 20 Hals. Laws Eng. 568
    • Silsby v. Trotter (1878) 29 N. J. Eq. 228
    • Young v. Ellis (i895) 9i Va. 297, 2I S. E. 480.
    • Scott v. Laws, supra note 9.
  • 23
    This reference contains 3 citations:
    • Sutherland v. Heathcote [i892] I Ch. 475, 483
    • Caldwell v. Fulton (i858) 31 Pa. 475
    • Grubb v. Bayard (085I, C. C. 3d) 2 Wall. Jr. 8i, Fed. Cas. No. 5849.
  • 24
    This reference contains 3 citations:
    • Scott v. Laws, supra note 9
    • Moore v. Indian Camp Coal Co. (1907) 75 Ohio St. 493, 8o N. E. 6.
    • Chartiers Block Coal Co. v. Mellon, supra note 12.
  • 25
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • Gill v. Fletcher, supra note 8
    • Transcontinental Oil Co. v. Emmerson (i921) 298 Ill. 394, 13i N. E. 645.
  • 26
    This reference contains 6 citations:
    • Grubb v. Bayard, supra note 23
    • Caldwell v. Fulton, supra note 23.
    • States Oil Corp. v. Ward (I922, Tex. Com. App.) 236 S. W. 446
    • Texas Co. v. Daugherty (19I5) I07 Tex. 226, I76 S. W. 7I7
    • Oil & Pipe Line Co. v. Teel (1902) 95 Tex. 586, 68 S. W. 979
    • Leonard v. Caruthers (I92I, Tex. Civ. App.) 236 S. W. i89.
  • 27
    Moore v. Indian Camp Coal Co., supra note 24.
  • 28
    This reference contains 3 citations:
    • Tiley v. Moyers (i862) 43 Pa. 404
    • Kelly v. Keys (i906) 2I3 Pa. 295, 62 AtI. 9ii
    • Austin v. Huntsville Coal Co. (i88o) 72 Mo. 535.
  • 29
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • Baker v. Hart (i890) 123 N. Y. 470, 25 N. E. 948
    • Chetham v. Williamson (0804, K. B.) 4 East, 469.
  • 30
    This reference contains 4 citations:
    • Mountjoy's Case (1583)
    • Coke, Littleton, 164 b
    • Stockbridge Iron Co. v. Hudson Iron Co. (1871) I07 Mass. 290.
    • Grubb v. Bayard, supra note 23.
  • 31
    This reference contains 11 citations:
    • Ives v. Sams (0596) Cro. Eliz. 52I
    • Clap v. Draper (i8o8) 4 Mass. 265
    • Williams v. Triche (i902) I07 La. 92, 3I So. 926
    • Board of Supervisors v. Imperial Naval Stores Co. (i908) 93 Miss. 822, 47 So. I77
    • Young v. Camp Mfg. Co. (i9io) iio Va. 678, 66 S. E. 843
    • Tiffany, op. cit. sec. 261
    • 13 Cyc. 651, 679
    • (1922) 31YALE LAW JOURNAL, 328
    • NOTES (1904) 17HARV. L. REV.411
    • (1914) 28 ibid. 114
    • Yellow Poplar Co. v. Thompson's Heirs (igo8) io8 Va. 612, 62 S. E. 358
  • 32
    This reference contains 4 citations:
    • Morris v. Salina County Coal Co. (i9i8) 2II Iii. App. I78
    • Penman v. Jones (19I7) 256 Pa. 4i6, io0 Atl. I043
    • Professor Hohfeld. Faulty Analysis in Easement and License Cases (19I7) 27YALE LAW JOURNAL, 66
    • Hall v. Harvey Coal & Coke Co. (I92I, W. Va.) io8 S. E. 49I.
  • 33
    Supra note 13.
  • 34
    This reference contains 3 citations:
    • Cardigan v. Armitage (I823, K. B.) 2 Barn. & Cress. i97
    • Caldwell v. Fulton (i858) 3I Pa. 475
    • Lindley, op. cit. sec. 812
  • 35
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • Moore v. Indian Camp Coal Co., supra note 24
    • Duke of Hamilton v. Graham, supra note 1.
  • 36
    This reference contains 8 citations:
    • Clayborn case, supra note 13.
    • Chartiers Block Coal Co. v. Mellon, supra note 12
    • McBurney v. Glenmary Coal and Coke Co., supra note 9
    • supra note 31
    • Young v. Camp Mfg. Co. (i910) iio Va. 678, 66 S. E. 843
    • Smith v. Ramsey (1914) ii6 Va. 530, 82 S. E. i89
    • Beatty v. Mathewson (i908) 40 Can. Sup. Ct. 557.
    • Hahn v. Baker Lodge (i89i) 2I Or. 30, 27 Pac. i66
  • 37
    Supra note 1, at p. 181
  • 38
    Hill v. Tupper (i863, Exch.) 2 Hurl. & Colt. I20.
  • 39
    herwood v. Greater Monmouth Vein Coal Co. (192I, Iowa) I85 N. W. 279.
  • 40
    This reference contains 3 citations:
    • Genett v. D. & H. Canal Co. (i8go) I22 N. Y. 505, 25 N. E. 922
    • McCracken v. Gumbert (i89o) I3I Pa. 36, i8 AtI. io68
    • St. Louis Trust Co. v. Galloway Coal Co. (19I3, C. C. A. 5th) 20i Fed. I022.
  • 41
    Schobert v. Pittsburgh Coal & Min. Co., supra note 17.
  • 42
    This reference contains 2 citations:
    • Pruett v. O'Gara Coal Co. (i9ii) i65 Ill. App. 470.
    • Friedline v. Hoffman (I922, Pa.) ii5 Atl. 84g.